I agree on the WOW factor. I too like to do things unconventionally.
You put the V8 in a CJ-8?
I think there's the difference. The CJ8 has a longer engine compartment than a CJ5, like the original poster said he has.
The bullnose Jeepsters and CJ8's were built to take the length of the I6, and didn't some come with the AMC V8's? I think it's only about 5" longer up front, but that little bit sure makes it easier. (He He - I've been told all my life another 5" would make a difference.)
My good '69 Jeepster had the 225, I was going to fit the 350 from my military in it - the longer 350 trans probably would not hurt much, since the Jeepster is longer. My wife talked me into selling it.
I still have another Jeepster right now, but I don't think it's worth fooling with.
I'll take some pics of my M38a1 - the same as a CJ5, to show how tight that 350 fits. It's doable, just lots of work. Both front and rear ends of the longer V8 block create issues. That's why I suggested a Buick engine, at least the distributor would be more accessible.
The trans needs to be something much shorter than the GM 350 - it'd be nice to have a driveshaft that can move up and down a little.
No doubt about it - the extra 2 cylinders does make a difference in power.
My next project might be either breathing some life into the M38a1 by lengthening it, modifying the suspension, making a new cage, and getting a more acceptable trans in it - I'd love to have something with brute power for a change.
Or I might first make my Tracker into a variable length wheelbase. I already have most of the parts to do it, I just need to get started on it.
Yes, the 4.3 is a V8 with 2 cylinders missing, but one of the things that make it easier too is it's a 60 degree block, as opposed to the 225 and 231's and V8's 90 degree blocks. Narrower helps too, especially for the exhaust around the steering.
He He - when you look at the 4.3 engine undressed, it's so small it looks like it should be out of a rice burner!
I remember your posting on the Jeepster board many times too. We've mildly disagreed on some things, but agreed most of the time. It's all a case of sharing one's knowledge, experience, and dreams.
Often there's not just one way of doing things, sometimes one way may be easier or work better. That's where sharing ideas comes in. It can also stop one from making a mistake that we've already experienced! (He He - I have lots of experience with what doesn't work or how to do it the hard way.)
I'll post the pics later today - gotta take them first.