I've always been a die hard Synthetic Mobil 1 fan. Recently I've been talking with Kevin who has been an oil expert for over 20 years. He sent me this MS Word document which shows LE (Lubrication Engineers) Synthetic out-performing Mobil 1 Synthetic on a certified Falex wear test.
Pennzoil Fail N
Mororcraft Fail N
Western Auto Fail N
Valvoline Durablend Fail N
Castrol GTX Fail N
Mopar Pass 19
Valvoline All Climate Pass 17
Total Quartz 5000 Pass 17
Phillips 66 Tropartic Pass 17
GM Goodwrench Pass 16
Mobil Pass 16
Honda Pass 14
Toyota Pass 14
Havoline Formula 3 Pass 14
Mobil-1 Synthetic Pass 12
Quaker State Synthetic Pass 11
Lubrication Engineers Pass 6
(Synthetic)
The lower the number, the better the oil protects from wear.
In the Falex Pin & Vee Block Wear Test, a rotating steel pin is compressed between two steel blocks with a V shaped grove in each. The test specimens are immersed in the test oil. The blocks are loaded against the pin with a force of 350 lbs. For a five minute break-in period. After the break-in period the load on the rotating pin is increased to 600 lbs. The load is maintained at this level for 15 minutes. At this point, the wear on the pin and blocks is evaluated by counting the number of "teeth" on the wheel used to apply the load. A wear depth of 0.001 inch corresponds to 14.410 teeth on the loading wheel. The test is started at ambient temperature and the sample oil temperature increases from frictional heating. This is somewhat like "Cold engine start," which produces the highest engine wear rates.
Mobil 1 did have the best Oxidation TFOUT where LE came in 2nd. The oxidation TFOUT isn't as important as the wear test above but should have a high number.
Mobil 1 509
Lubrication Engineers 481
Other oil TFOUT scores:
323
247
237
231
222
221
219
218
207
193
190
166
157
153
121
Mobil 1 is still a great oil but I think LE may be a better a choice.
As of now, LE is not sold in stores but can be purchased though outlets like
http://www.mag-hytec.com/. The price is almost the same as Mobil 1.
Shawn
87 K5
few mods