Off Roading Forums banner

What should I do?

  • Trade the TJ for a YJ

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Part out the TJ

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Keep the TJ and spend the next 4 years trying to monkey with it

    Votes: 0 0.0%
1 - 20 of 30 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
4,183 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Restoring my tj back to "stock" form is just not making sense to me in any aspect besides the fact that my jeep will "live again" though that really doesn't excite me 1 bit. The amount of time and $$ it will take to make my jeep "stock" again and get rid of all the 1/2 assed mods is out of this world. Here's a list of stuff that my jeep needs to make it nice and "stock" like again in no paticular order:

full body, every pannel (tub all hacked up and dented, windshield frame dented and windshield cracked, tail gate is mangled and has 2 or 3 large holes, grill is dented and cut for turn signals, hood cut, fenders), All new wiring harness, trans has a major leak and may be trashed since it would go in nutral or drive (but only 1st worked), motor has lots of electrical gremlins and leaks oil, t-case and linkage, 8.8 needs bearings, seals, calipers, rotors, i have a 260 joint d30 for it so that needs 297 joint shafts, need a custom track bar to deal with the drilled out mount, need a new pitman arm to replace the drilled out stock arm, Control arms are mangled, i don't own a set of 4 of the same sized tires for it or any wheels besides factory 15x6 steelies, needs a tire carrier, Needs pretty much a complete interior besides seats and those need to be cleaned, new dash, center coucle, steering colum cover (maybe new colum), 3 way switch, none of the dash electricals worked after the roll, needs the battery mount put back in the engine compartment, rear crossmember on the frame is pretty tweaked, control arm mounts tweaked, all new seatbelts except for 1 in the rear, i'd either need to make a new skid or find a used one since mine is gone
new shocks (2 or 3 of the current shocks are blown, drive shaft u-joints if i decide to use a stock rear shaft, new rear shaft if i go with an sye, exhaust and probably cat, front brake lines (drilled out for d44 caliper bolts)

So pretty much the only stock things i will be using will be the frame, 8.8 rear (after lots of work), motor (but needs some work), maybe the trans if it can be rescued, master cylinder, steering box, part of the steering colum, front drive shaft, seats after a good cleaning, maybe some heater parts, 1 rear seat belt.

To me that sounds like a huge list of parts i don't have the $$ for and there's no chance within a year or maybe even 3 my jeep would be back alive and in stock form which almost seems pointless to me. If i don't do all those things then i will still have a half assed jeep in some ways that looks like crap or runs like crap and i'm sure if i ever got it together i'd find many more gremlins once i stared wheeling it and driving it again. I have the opertunity to trade my jeep to a buddy that owns a 4x4 shop and he would probably make the jeep into some kind of trail rig so it would live again for all of you worried about "pleasing the jeep gods." In exchange for my jeep i would get an '87 YJ (258, puke and go, 231, 110k) and parts to make it into a decent easy-moderate trail rig (31" muds, cage, mild lift, ax15 to replace the puke and go when it goes). Once i'd get it i would fix the little gremlins (oil leaks, rust, another other "stock" issues that should be fixed) and do mods i can handle like rocker guards and other skid plates, swapping in tfi and a mc 2100 or maybe fuel injection, maybe an 8.8 with a lock right, cb, and put my winch on it.

I've learned a lot from the distruction of my tj and now know how to do a lot of things the right way because i did them the wrong way on my tj, i could probably make a list of over 100 things i would do differently with out a problem. I no longer want a "wana be" hardcore rig (the direction i thought my tj was going before i realized it was beyond help) and want a rig that i'm able to drive every day, wheel most trails (how many trails at the badlands can you no get through with 31's, a locker, winch and some decent driving?) if i can't make it now that i have a decent winch (picked up a warn m8000) i can always winch through something instead of giving it 20 tries and beating the hell outa my heep, will be able to make the 6 1/2 hour road trip home with out too much trouble, and is something that is good for me to practice my wheeling skills in so maybe in 2 or 3 years when i have enough $$ and experiance i can build a decent "hardcore" trail rig the right way. I live in wheeling country now and might as well take advantage of, who knows where i'll end up when i'm out of school.

I figure spending my time doing mods i know i can handle, fixing broken parts as they come up and getting experiance on the trail instead of spending 4 years trying to convince my self to wheel my daily driver and being miserable in my shop screwing with tons of gremlins. I figure wheeling and getting experiance on the trail then dealing with my disaster is more benifical to me as a person as a person over all.

I know most of the people on the board feel that i should try and fix it but most of the people i wheel and wrench with all the time at school, several people i used to wrench with all the time (i didn't wheel alot because the pos was always down with rigged issues), and my self feel that it's a lost cause to try and fix the tj along with.

Here's a picture of the heep's current state



BarrelRoll
 

Attachments

· Registered
Joined
·
4,601 Posts
we already talked about this on AIM but im posting it here so other people can comment on it.....

i say since you dont NEED a jeep...get a cheapo daily driver like an escort or something reliable. then spend some time fixing the jeep slowly and doing it right. you Dont NEED a jeep, its a hobby, take the time and do it right and you'll learn a lot about your vehicle and what it and you are capable of doing. by going slowly you can avoiding having to dish out all yur money at once...you can piece it together as you get more cash.

It will teach you

1) patience!
2) good things come to those who wait
3) the easy way out isnt the best way out (which is how you got into this mess)
3) instant gratification is nothing compared to something you've had to work for long and hard

Remember that true jeeping is not just driving, its also working and understanding the vehicle. its kinda like in the jeep creed
, you are nothing w/o your jeep, and you jeep is nothing w/o you

dont take the i-just-knocked-up-my-girlfriend-so-i'm-going-to-run-away approach. fix yur mistakes,

sometimes theres more to learning than realizing you did something wrong. you need to do it right before you learn the whole lesson. getting rid of the TJ and getting that YJ will only mean you only learned half a lesson
 

· Registered
Joined
·
688 Posts
Andy, you just knocked your girlfriend up. Now get the hell out of town.

Ha. Just kidding. But seriously guys, look at that pic. What a pile of mistakes - as long as Andy's learned from his mistakes, why should he have to go back and fix them? Why not start out clean slate and just not make the mistakes in the first place?

Trade the TJ. That thing looks like it will never be a reliable, safe vehicle, even for trail use. I've often told people that a YJ is the BEST jeep to buy as a barebones starter vehicle, which is what Andy's looking for. The BA10/5 is the only drawback here, and I've got a spare one he can *have* if he wants it (it's just a big paperweight in my garage now...)

Hopefully, in 2 years, we won't be having a "Restoring the YJ isn't making sense to me" thread! but i'm not worried.

-p
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,722 Posts
I guess your poll dosen't reflect my opinion so I will post it here. What is wrong with keeping it and making it a "Good" trail vehicle. I may be all screwed up, but when it comes to trail vehicles, it does not have to be perfect and as for the body,, it just needs too hold up the passangers and keep mud from flying in your face... I would keep it as a traiol project... But do whatever suits you.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,183 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Greg Jeeps arn't human, you see all the time when people post pics of recked jeeps atleast you are ok you can replace the jeep, and some times an aborition is the right way (not trying to start any beliefes debates here just refering to my jeep).

Already with the work i've been doing after i messed up the tj i've done things the right way instead of the wrong 1/2 assed way.

BarrelRoll
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,183 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Making it into a trail vehicle would be ok but take almost as much work. A trail only vehicle doesn't work very well for me back at school. Most of the wheeling there isn't like the badlands, you drive to the trail (any where from 5 min to an hour), wheel the trail and come out at a completely different spot, some times miles away from where the tow rig would be parked. I'm not really in a situation where a trail only jeep works very good for my, my daily driver truck is on it's last legs and i need to keep it alive as long as possible. Having the truck and trailer is how i make most of my money though (selling parts, need to be able to pick up parts rigs) but i don't need to daily drive it.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,757 Posts
I'd strip it down to nothing. Kee the parts that are good and throw away whats bad.
Then you have 3 options.
1. find a wrecked TJ with a bent frame. they sell dirt cheap and the wireing is all perfect. swap in the good parts, buy a few body parts.
2. sell all the good parts on ebay and get something else
3. Do what I had to do when I destroyed my first jeep.....I drove a 79 plymouth horizon for a couple years.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
729 Posts
40 seconds? But I want it NOW! -- said Homer to the microwave...

"You got to know when to hold 'em; know when to fold 'em.
Know when to walk away; know when to RUN." -- Cash

If you think trading is a good deal -- trade away. That TJ looks pretty ruff. A drivable jeep for a rebuildable jeep sounds like a good deal to me. --
Mike
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,971 Posts
I haven't weighed in on this subject yet, but have been following it. My vote was to trade it. No matter how much advice is given to rebuild the TJ, if the desire isn't there, it will never happen. And the list of repairs...wow. Nowhere near insurrountable, but to make it back into a daily driver...too much. As for the advice of getting a cheapo daily driver and rebuild the TJ, well, it's not bad advice but I for one can't imagine not having a Jeep as a daily driver. I got my Scrambler as a daily driver when my Commando project started to look like the neverending story. And...just like my wife feared, I have been modding the Scrambler while the Commando sits. Some day I'll get back on the Commando, but like most of us I just don't have the time or money to run 2 projects at the same time. Lastly, Sounds like the XJ is what you really want, you just want our input. I say go with what you want- trade her off, learn from past mistakes, and slowly and sensibly build from a fresh start. Just my .02, but I spent alot of $$ to have that .02 left!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,183 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
It's a done deal, the tj is leaving my house tomorow and the yj is comming home with me. I'm getting the yj with full soft top and doors, 4" procrap lift, 33" pro comp muds, and a front cage for my tj. To me it makes sense, the jeep doesn't leak anything bad and shifts and drives fine. The jeep should be ready for new years day at the badlands.

BarrelRoll
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,183 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
I'll post pics when it gets back, probably won't be till late at night. I'll post pics of mods for "approval." It's stock now and i won't have the lift and tires till around xmass time but it will be alive and pumping for new years day at the badlands.

BarrelRoll
 

· Official Curmudgeon
Joined
·
5,207 Posts
In reply to:

"You got to know when to hold 'em; know when to fold 'em. Know when to walk away; know when to RUN." -- Cash

[/ QUOTE ]

What????????

Kenny Rogers "The Gambler"
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,520 Posts
yep.. that is kenny rogers... not johnny cash..

and i think you chumped out.. its YOUR jeep... for whatever reason you did what you did... now.. if you dont like it.. then fix it... if you dont.. then i dont think you'll learn a whole lot..
then of course i also agree with.. if the desire isnt there.. then.. it will never get done..
ive learned alot over the years with all of my vehicles.. and i pretty much have it down for me... meaning.. i dont cut corners.. i used to alot.. but not now.. i have been jeepless for 2 years.. and itll be a few more years by the looks of things.. but i dont mind.. i work on it.. and i am making it how i want too.. so i have to wait.. so what.. when the wait is over.. it will be much more rewarding.. knowing i did it.. and i did it my way...
 
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top