"Sometimes Floats don't."!!!!!!!!"
I like that, so true.
The float doesn't have much side to side clearance in the bowl, it could be dragging on the side.
If the float is able to drop down far enogh, the taper on the bottom can jam it in the down position - that should be checked - don't depend on the float drop specs - often wrong. Just measure the bottom of the bowl to the gasket, then hold the top with the foat dropping to make sure it can't touch bottom.
Or, like was said, a piece of trash in the seat.
Or, the little spring on the float - the one that pulls the needle down - it does NOT go through the hole like it looks like it should. That can hold the float needle/seat open.
In any case, ya gotto go in and look. It's not supposed to be so full it bubbles out the top.
Plastic floats - make sure you don't touch them with your fingers - the tiny amount of acid dissolves the thin surface film on them, causing them to absorb gas. They should put a warning on them - just like halogen bulbs!