Off-Road Forums & Discussion Groups

Off-Road Forums & Discussion Groups (
-   Jeep-Short Wheelbase (
-   -   Why electric fans? (

CJDave 09-22-2001 07:11 AM

Why electric fans?
[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img] As you may have noticed, autos now use electric fans on the sideways-engine models. Obviously, the use of electric fans came because they could no longer include the fan in the accessory drive group on the crank pulley end of the engine. However, there IS another good reason to use an electric fan, DESPITE the fact that reliability is a questionmark, and current draw is fairly high. FUEL MILEAGE is improved by using an electric fan setup over clutch fans or direct-drive fans. Because the HORSEPOWER REQUIRED to drive a fan blade goes up as the CUBE OF THE DIFFERENCE IN when you double the RPM, the new HP required is 2 X 2 X 2 or EIGHT TIMES the original HP. When a clutch fan locks in on a grade at 3500 engine RPM, can you IMAGINE what the HP requirement is? The blade has to be such that it cools at 1500 RPM, so it has a lot of bite. At 3500 RPM, it is a HUGE power-robber. In industrial applications I have to add one gallon of diesel per hour if the engine has a direct-drive fan. However, we DO have the luxury in stationary applications of knowing exactly what the constant engine RPM will be and the fans are chosed specifically for that speed so no extra HP is consumed.....theoretically.....beyond what it takes to do the job. In the automotive world, consessions must be made to cover all possible conditions, so fans have to be made for the worst possible scenario, and that means BIG blades. Even though electric fans are actually driven by the alternator; and the alternator puts more drag on the engine because of it, you have the advantage of running the fans at constant, optimum RPM at all times, and no overspeeding has to occur to waste HP. So the overall HP input to the system is actually less with electric fans. One thing about it; when an elctric fan is OFF, it's off, no drag is present; and when it is on, it is immediately at optimum efficiency, regardless of engine RPM.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img]

A Jeep Skunkworks run by Moonguys[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/wink.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/laugh.gif[/img], buildin' the ultimate SNOJEEP!

jeepgod 09-22-2001 05:33 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
your point being????


<font color=orange>survival is instinct, but living takes guts</font color=orange>

CJDave 09-22-2001 09:32 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/blush.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/blush.gif[/img]....ah...only that there ARE some advantages to going with electric fans.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/crazy.gif[/img] It isn't for all applications, but a properly engineered electric fan system can have some measureable benefits.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/crazy.gif[/img]

A Jeep Skunkworks run by Moonguys[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/wink.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/laugh.gif[/img], buildin' the ultimate SNOJEEP!

jeepgod 09-22-2001 10:09 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
in some cross sectional engine.. thats about it.. lol

<font color=orange>survival is instinct, but living takes guts</font color=orange>

Sycho15 09-23-2001 12:12 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
I put an electric fan in my Wrangler (haven't wired it up yet though) for its underwater abilities. Namely, I can turn it off when I submerge the engine. Normally its not an issure, but after a big storm (or even a medium-sized one like Gabriel) there can be a few spots in town to put my headlights under....

Then there is off-road. Plenty of ponds, rivers, ditches, pools, and whatever else I can find that has fairly deep standing water. Moving water is better of course- washes the mud off my drivetrain.

'89 Comanche, '89 Wrangler, '74 Postal

utahjeepr 09-23-2001 08:26 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
Well, as an ex: drag racer, hot rodder, mad scientist engine swapper; I love electric fans. They are a great tool. Like any other tool they cannot be used all the time, but they are very beneficial when you need 'em.

For one thing it takes less than 1/5 of 1 HP to generate enough electricity to spin the average electric fan. Engine driven fans can suck up anywhere from 4-10 hp. Swapping to an electric fan can sometimes mean maybe .03-.05 seconds off 1/4 mile time in your streeet macine/weekend racer. That may not mean s#it in a Jeep, but it does equate out in another area as well... fuel economy. That is the primary reason for clutch fans and electric fans being installed by manufacturers. Electric fans help the manufacturers meet federal CAFE standards. Swapping to an electric may be worth 1 MPG or more on the highway, less around town.

However, the main reason that I personally like electrics is their versatility and their ability to be squeezed into small spaces. I have performed or assisted in way more than my share of engine swaps. Among others, I have built a 440 six pack 1/2 ton '82 Dodge Ram; a 427 tunnel rammed '78 Camaro; a 307 Chevy powered, rear wheel drive VW Scirocco; and a tube framed, front engine, rear wheel drive 454 VW bug.

Ever try to stick a V-8 into an early CJ? Sure, starting in '72 they made it easy but that 3'' makes a huge difference. An electric fan makes it possible.

Electric fans may not be needed in every application, but they are worth their weight in gold when you need 'em.

Hell, my Cummins powered M-715 would not be possible (well OK, not as "easy") without an electric pusher in front of the radiator. Without the engine driven fan the Cummins fit perfectly, otherwise I would have had to modify the firewall to get the room. I overkilled it and put 2 1800 CFM pancake pushers up front, and it hasn't seen the other side of 180*.

September 11, 2001- We will not forget! We will not forgive!

CJDave 09-23-2001 08:40 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/smile.gif[/img] Heh heh.....Tom, you JUST CAN'T leave well enough alone! Don't you know that when you do engine swaps it beats up on the self esteem of the guy who designed the vehicle with the STOCK engine?[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/wink.gif[/img] THINK how many automotive engineers are on anti-depressants because of you.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/laugh.gif[/img]

A Jeep Skunkworks run by Moonguys[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/wink.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/laugh.gif[/img], buildin' the ultimate SNOJEEP!

H8monday 09-23-2001 06:44 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
I installed an electric fan on Friday.
The main reason, I wanted to run an electric, was to eliminate the threat of putting my fan blades through the radiator. This is a very real threat, with some of the up coming events I will be running, as I am anticipating quite a few rollovers in the next couple of months.
I bought a Flex-a-lite Black Magic M150 through, for $183.00, and went about installing it. I wired it with a cut off switch, and a manual activation switch, (both in the cockpit), it took about 2 1/2 hours to install with it including the electrical.
I ran it this weekend on the Rubicon, and I was hoping to be able to give the report of how great it is and how happy I am with the set up. But instead, I have to report that I just removed it and its getting cleaned up and returned.
It had a couple of performance downfalls.
1: It just couldnt keep the engine as cool as the stock Lincoln 18" clutch fan, that I was running. The M150, is a 15" fan with a cowling and they say it moves 2800 cfm. I mounted it right in the center of my aluminum radiator and set the T stat to 190 degrees while ideling, when I started climbing Ice House Road( the steep 20 mile pavement road up to the Con), it immediately jumped to 220 and even 230, with my stock fan it never went over 200 degrees.
Also it took much longer for a cool down period when I stopped to let it cool.
2: It draws quite a bit of power, I could watch my ammeter drop by a couple of volts every time it came on. We had to help out a guy who had gotten his van stuck, in the middle of the night, with lights on, winch running, and fan wanting to come on, it was a heel of a burden on my 140 amp alternator, so I shut it off while I was winching, but then the temp went high, and the high underhood temperature began making the alternator work under extremely ineficient conditions(to the point that it started whining, which it has never done before).Even my power steering pump started grinding and whirring because of the engine compartment temperatures. Durring daytime trail conditions (90 degrees, and no additional electrical draw from lighting), it maintained good temperatures.
All in all, it was a waist of my time for my 5.0 HO application. I have an old 18" flex fan that I am going to install this evening, just to compare it to thelincoln clutch fan, Ill post the results later this week.

89 YJ
Adversity is imminent, versatility is mandatory, misery is optional.

WILL 09-23-2001 06:51 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
"my ammeter drop by a couple of volts "


ozarkjeep 09-23-2001 06:58 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
semantics Will!

ammeter=amps, voltmeter=volts

whats been up Will?


I love the U.S.A.

H8monday 09-23-2001 07:24 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
Oooops, I meant my voltmeter, I dont even have an ammeter.

89 YJ
Adversity is imminent, versatility is mandatory, misery is optional.

WILL 09-23-2001 09:00 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
Sorry, Jeff, I just couldn't resist.

Ozark, I'm heading to Clayton this weekend. It's been a few weeks since I've been in the dirt and I think I'll have a light enough homework load this weekend that I can spare 1-1/2 days away.

CJDave 09-23-2001 09:05 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/crazy.gif[/img] I have been looking at fans for MONTHS and one of the things that did not add up was the advertised CFM vs current draw. I was leary of the advertised 2500-2800 CFM and thought it might be a fairy tale. The Ferd Contour fans that we will be using draw 30+ amps together and really howl at rated RPM.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img] You know.......there are times when I wish I had BOTH an ammeter and a voltmeter.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/crazy.gif[/img] ALthough I was NO PROBLEM to see when my pickup alternator gave up the ghost when we were runnin' hard across Wyoming recently. I glanced at the gauge and, was down in the red.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/crazy.gif[/img] Luckily we were carryin' a spare.[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/smile.gif[/img]

A Jeep Skunkworks run by Moonguys[img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/wink.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/tongue.gif[/img][img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/laugh.gif[/img], buildin' the ultimate SNOJEEP!

sloop 09-23-2001 09:31 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
soo. does anyone have an electric fan success story? I might be interested in going electric on my 258 if I can get a junkyard bargain.

83 CJ-7 and 76 CJ-7 with stuff

LWhite 09-23-2001 10:42 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
Swaping a different fan into a 84-89 300zx is supposed to "regain 20hp".
And shave maybe .2 off your 0-60? It'd get you to 6.9 if that was true. no idea really

But would it help any off roading with a electric one in a jeep?

"motorcraft added 200+ horsepower!!!"
the ricer way of thinking ;)

ducmon900 09-24-2001 10:06 PM

Re: Why electric fans?
Thats exactly why I went with my belt driven clutch fan. It may eat a little horsepower but I'm not running it down a track. I was afraid that if I got into a heavy winching session that it would draw too much juice. Reliability was second, I couldn't image being in timbucktwo and having the fan burn up or possibly getting wet and quitting. The only drawback I see with the old belt driven is water crossings and the possibilty of ruining a good radiator. ken

**DONOTDELETE** 09-25-2001 03:39 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
h8, you might try the z28 camero dual fan setup. i know that is what tom elliston uses for his conversions and with good results. i run a dual SPAL 11' setup and they work good too. they are in thier own shroud and fits the jeep rad perfectly. i had all kinds of cooling troubles with different fan setups but this is the one! it works with my old 351w and a cj4 row rad it stayed nice and cool so i imagine your aluminum radiator would work even better with it.

brian wilson
80 cj5 "high 5"
stretched to 100" wb

GreenMachine 09-25-2001 09:23 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
Believe it or not I have been running one of the Advanced auto electric fans in my jeep since 1995 with no problems. I did have to replace the very first on because I had it inside the grill in front of the radiator and it caught a stick. It saved the radiator though. On my 360 I ran the largest they sell I believe it is a 18 inch. It kept my 360 at 180 degrees on the autometer during the summer. The one I have now is a 15 inch I believe and it stays at 150 degrees all the time as long as I leave it on(I think I have a thermostat stuck open). I did put a new water pump on my 360 when I started redoing it and I put a new pump on the 4.3. My radiator is a heavy duty 3 core brass model.

<font color=green> GreenMachine </font color=green>

H8monday 09-25-2001 09:28 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
I have never had an overheating problem, I was really just looking for a cooling system which had less chance of ruining the radiator durring a roll over.
After experimenting with what many people consider a top of the line, E fan, I just dont see an electric as being the best way to go in my case. It is just too much of a burden on the electrical system, in my opinion. I use a 1000w AC inverter, quite often to operate my grinder, impact wrench and drill, for trail repairs. The added demand of lights, would mean that durring a night time repair, I could be forced to shut off the fan, durring repairs, to save the batteries and alternator.

89 YJ
Adversity is imminent, versatility is mandatory, misery is optional.

utahjeepr 09-25-2001 10:15 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
H8, why don't you quit messing around. With your electrical demands you need a PTO driven generator, or possibly an on-board nuclear reactor. ;-)

September 11, 2001- We will not forget! We will not forgive!

Mel85CJ 09-25-2001 10:26 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
Do you know how many watts a grinder uses. We just put a dinky inverter on our '79, mainly to charge the video camera & have for things like a blender [img]/wwwthreads_images/icons/crazy.gif[/img] - I think it's only 450 watts - I was wondering if we could use a grinder with it.

"The only makeup I wear is never-seez"

JeepDaddy 09-25-2001 11:16 AM

Re: Why electric fans?
Electric fans have their place when a mechanical won't fit or when water is an issue.

Electrics do not pull as much air through a radiator as a mechanical fan. Their CFM rating is a best case scenario (i.e. not pulling air through a restriction such as a radiator).

A shrouded mechanical fan with a thermal clutch is the most effective cooling strategy in most situations. Think about electric fan is a fan blade driven by an electric motor driven by an alternator driven by the same belt as a mechanical fan. There are some efficiency losses in the energy transfer.

The thermal clutch normally starts to slip at about 1800 RPM - Higher if the air is hot. This prevents too much power loss at higher RPM.

1976 CJ7 304/TH400/QT/D30/AMC20
Front D44 in process.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2021 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2021 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1994-2009, VerticalScope Inc. // Off Road forums & discussion groups sitemap
side by side | atv | dirtbike | snowmobile | sandsport | competition | land use | Jeep | Toyota | Ford | GM

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome